Facebook encryption plans under fire after David Wilson case

Upset problem child with head in hands sitting on staircase concept for bullying, depression stress

Police fear end-to-end encryption of messages on Facebook will make it harder to detect abuse online - Credit: Getty Images/iStockphoto

Paedophiles may soon be able to hide behind a cloak of encryption when they prey on children over the internet.

That's the grim warning from police, as the Norfolk man dubbed one of Britain's most prolific online sex offenders was jailed  for 25 years after admitting a vile catalogue of abuse on children as young as four.

Police custody shot of David Wilson

David Wilson - Credit: National Crime Agency

Roofer David Wilson, 36, from Kirstead, King's Lynn, entered guilty pleas to 96 offences against 51 victims.

He posed as teenage girls on Facebook, grooming boys to send him indecent images, blackmailing some into performing increasingly obscene acts or abusing their siblings. 

Officers from the National Crime Agency moved in after being tipped off by the social media giant.

It told them a number of boys had been sending indecent images of themselves to an account purporting to be a 13-year-old girl. The fake account and others like it were eventually linked to Wilson.

But police fear changes to its app which will offer end-to-end encryption of messages mean Facebook may not be able to detect those who use it to abuse children in future.

Richard Porritt interviews Priti Patel MP at Westminster.EADT 9.10.12

Home Secretary Priti Patel is calling on Facebook to abandon plans to introduce end-to-end encryption on its platform, which could allow paedophiles to operate without being detected - Credit: Phil Morley

Home Secretary Priti Patel said: “The tireless efforts of the NCA have put a truly awful criminal behind bars, providing justice to those who suffered as well as protecting hundreds of potential victims.

Most Read

“This sickening case is a chilling reminder of how crucial it is that tech companies play their part in combating child sexual abuse.

“It is vital that Facebook do not press ahead without amending their current end-to-end-encryption plans, otherwise sick criminals like David Wilson could still be abusing children with impunity.”

Rob Jones

Rob Jones, director of threat leadership at the National Crime Agency - Credit: NCA

Rob Jones, the NCA's director of threat leadership, said: "It's the biggest single issue that's going to affect our ability to tackle child abuse online."

Mr Jones said in 2020, 4,500 people were arrested on suspicion of online abuse and 6,000 children were safeguarded after police received referrals from social media platforms which had detected obscene images.

More than 50pc came from Facebook. But encryption will mean fewer referrals, because social media platforms will not be able to see what material users are exchanging.

Facebook

Facebook's headquarters in California - Credit: Facebook

"Over the next few months, the privacy model they are creating effectively locks them out of their own network," said Mr Jones. "It creates a private place, where people like Wilson can masquerade as children.

“Facebook’s plans are a disaster for child safety and law enforcement and mean the very many other David Wilsons out there will not be caught.

“Criminals will be drawn to Facebook, emboldened and confident it’s a place they can search for children to sexually abuse with complete impunity."

Mr Jones said the change posed "a real threat" to the safety of children on social media platforms, which offenders used to target victims.

He added: “In 2019 Facebook made 15.8m global referrals of child sexual abuse material, they have been a huge help to lawful investigations and child safeguarding.

“But their plans will create a haven for child sex offenders to congregate to target children. It’s not too late for Facebook to change their mind.”

Chief Constable Simon Bailey at Norfolk Constabulary Headquarters, Wymondham. Photo : Steve Adams

Chief Constable Simon Bailey believes Facebook will be washing its hands of its responsibility to protect children if it brings in end-to-end encryption of messages sent on its platform - Credit: Steve Adams

Simon Bailey, Norfolk's Chief Constable, is the National Police Chief's Council's lead for child protection.

He said: "Facebook are responsible for the vast majority of referrals around child sexual abuse materials and the Facebook platform is used to share and distribute wholesale child sexual abuse material.

"Facebook know this and whilst they would argue they are doing everything they can, as demonstrated by the number of referrals to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, the fact is they still permit those images to be uploaded and shared, when the technology exists to prevent that.

"They know they have this huge problem and their answer is to put end-to-end encryption in so they can't see it.

"We all want and expect privacy to be applied for legitimate transactions and activity, but it cannot be right that paedophiles can expect their activity to be protected too."

Mr Bailey said he had raised the issue of encryption at "the very highest levels of government" and at national and international conferences.

He added: "In my opinion Facebook are washing their hand of their responsibility to protect children and to identify those who would seek to exploit children and young people.

“The information from Facebook was crucial in bringing Wilson to justice. Which is why I am concerned about Facebook planning to introduce further encryption and privacy protections, making it harder for us to prevent exploitation and find child sexual abusers like Wilson."

Close up of Unrecognizable man sitting at desk and working on laptop at night

Police fear end-to-end encryption will hamper their efforts to investigate online abuse - Credit: Getty Images/iStockphoto

In a statement, Facebook said: "“Child exploitation and grooming have no place on our platforms.

"Facebook has led the industry in developing new ways to prevent, detect, and respond to abuse and we will continue to work with law enforcement to combat criminal activity.

"End-to-end encryption is already the leading technology used by many services to keep people safe and we will build on our strong anti-abuse capabilities at WhatsApp when we roll it out on our other messaging services.

"For example, through a combination of advanced technology and user reports, WhatsApp bans around 250,000 accounts each month suspected of sharing child exploitative imagery.”

Become a Supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Become a Supporter