Councillor cleared after death crash
A senior councillor has been cleared of criminal charges relating to a car crash which killed a popular Waveney church minister. Harold Mangar, a Suffolk county councillor and former member of Suffolk Police Authority, was acquitted after a district judge ruled the collision which killed the Rev Stephanie Neal was an accident.
A senior councillor has been cleared of criminal charges relating to a car crash which killed a popular Waveney church minister.
Harold Mangar, a Suffolk county councillor and former member of Suffolk Police Authority, was acquitted after a district judge ruled the collision which killed the Rev Stephanie Neal was an accident.
Following the trial at Ipswich Magistrates' Court, Mrs Neal's sister said she was pleased with the verdict and spoke of her sympathy for Mr Mangar.
The court heard that Mr Mangar had been driving along the A145 at Shadingfield, near Beccles, on the evening of March 22 last year when his Mazda 626 car collided with Mrs Neal.
Mrs Neal, 71, who was the minister for Shadingfield, Sotterly, Stoven, Brampton, Weston and Westhall villages, had been on her way to a meeting at Shadingfield village hall at the time of the accident. She died of multiple injuries at the scene.
Mr Mangar, 70, of Colchester Road, Ipswich, told police he was travelling at 30mph prior to the accident and was on dipped headlights because he did not want to dazzle any on-coming vehicle.
- 1 Mum describes heartache year on from daughter's tragic death
- 2 North Norfolk road closed with drivers asked to avoid area
- 3 Body found in the sea at Great Yarmouth
- 4 Banksy work removed and put in museum due to local sensitivity
- 5 Police on hand as anti-vaccine protesters gather in city
- 6 Popular teacher, 55, died after falling down stairs, inquest hears
- 7 Investigations continue after woman on mobility scooter assaults man
- 8 Hope for WASPI women as MPs back compensation call
- 9 Teenager died of injuries six days after crash
- 10 Eight dogs up for adoption at a Norfolk rehoming centre
He said he had not seen the victim, who was dressed in dark clothing and carrying a torch with a failing battery, until the moment of impact, but he was later charged with driving without due care and attention and speeding.
The prosecution said he should not have been driving on dipped headlights because the oncoming vehicle was too far in the distance and said police experts estimated his speed to be between 36 and 41mph.
However, Mr Mangar, who denied both charges, was acquitted after a leading crash collision expert, Dr Darren Walsh, gave evidence to contradict the formula used to calculate his speed, saying he was more likely to be travelling at between 28 and 32mph.
His solicitor, Geoffrey Payne, had also argued it was “perfectly proper” for the reasonable driver to have had their headlights dipped at that particular time.
In acquitting Mr Mangar, District Judge David Cooper said: “I have to say I can find nothing in the Highway Code or any case that says one should drive full-beam in any given circumstances. There is nothing that says when driving through a particular unlit area that you should be on full beam.
“There is a sort of feeling that someone must be blamed. It's a blame culture that we live in. Accidents do happen. People do not necessarily have to be to blame. There can be a conjunction of tragic circumstances that produce, well, tragedy.”
Speaking after the case, Mr Mangar said: “This has been the worst 14 months of my life. My sincere condolences go to Mrs Neal's family and friends. She lost her life. I have always maintained this was a pure accident. I'm really happy to be acquitted on both charges.”
Mrs Neal's sister, Celia Richards, who was present at the hearing, also said she was pleased with the result and said friends and family of the deceased did not blame father-of-three Mr Mangar.
She said: “We are absolutely pleased. In our view this was a tragic accident. The last 14 months must have been awful for Mr Mangar. We think the outcome is as it should be. We do not blame him at all. We think he's gone through hell.”
Mr Mangar, the councillor for Bridge ward in Ipswich, stepped down from his position on Suffolk Police Authority when it emerged he would face criminal charges in relation to the accident, but said he hoped he could be reappointed.