Defra explores SFI changes after farm nature payments fiasco

Defra is 'exploring alternatives to a first come, first served application process' after a chaotic six-hour scramble for Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) funding <i>(Image: Denise Bradley)</i>
Defra is 'exploring alternatives to a first come, first served application process' after a chaotic six-hour scramble for Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) funding (Image: Denise Bradley)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

After a frantic six-hour scramble for nature payments provoked fury from farmers this week, the government says it is considering changes to the application system for next year.

The Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI), part of the government's post-Brexit system of payments rewarding nature-friendly farming practices, was relaunched this year after an overhaul which included a £100,000 cap for individual businesses.

The second application window for SFI2026 opened on Tuesday morning, but slammed shut less than six hours later after its entire £253m budget was allocated on the first day - leaving many farmers missing out on payments.

In response to industry criticism, the government is "exploring alternatives to a first come, first served application process" when the scheme reopens in 2027.

A Defra spokesman said: "We know some farmers who wanted to join SFI26 will be disappointed not to have secured an agreement this year.

"We will look to open the 2027 offer as early as possible to ensure farmers can access funding.

"We are ready to look at how we can improve SFI for next year – continuing our close work with farmers and stakeholders by listening to experiences and learning lessons from this window. As part of this, we are exploring alternatives to a first come, first served application process for SFI in 2027."

Rural industry leaders said the high demand proved the need for a bigger SFI budget - and called for urgent improvements to the application process.

National Farmers' Union (NFU) vice-president Robyn Munt said: “We have warned Defra for months that the available budget would not meet demand of those farmers wanting to deliver for the environment and sustainable farming.

 “Yet again, Defra has created a position where there are the ‘haves’ and the ‘have nots’ in the sector based purely on the speed of pressing a button."

Cath Crowther, East regional director for the Country Land and Business Association (CLA East), said: “We have always been clear that in this round of SFI, there was insufficient budget allocated to enable farmers to continue delivering for the environment on behalf of society.

"Today [Tuesday] has been a scramble for thousands of farmers desperately trying not to be left behind and we urge Defra to provide clear guidance to farmers who – despite their best efforts – will be unlucky and fail to secure an SFI26 agreement."

Defra said, in anticipation of high demand, an extra £20m had been allocated to the SFI26 Window 2 budget, on top of the £50m added as part of the government's drought relief package this summer, bringing the total to £253m.

Around 12,200 applications were submitted during Window 2, meaning the average agreement value applied for was about £20,700.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos