Stephen Crocker, Norwich Theatre: Your news may lie to you

US President Donald Trump is threatening to sue the BBC over the way an interview was edited. Picture: PA <i>(Image: Suzanne Plunkett/PA Wire)</i>
US President Donald Trump is threatening to sue the BBC over the way an interview was edited. Picture: PA (Image: Suzanne Plunkett/PA Wire)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

Theatre thrives on the implicit and inherent contract with audiences around invention.

It invites audiences into worlds of bias, fantasy, and interpretation.

Storytelling in this realm bends reality to illuminate deeper truths, provoke emotion, and spark dialogue.

Recent days and week have made me ponder how journalism is and must be different.

Its power lies in resisting those theatrical impulses.

Where theatre can distort to reveal, journalism is a forum for facts, not fiction.

The BBC has long been regarded as a global benchmark for impartial journalism.

Its reputation rests on a promise: to inform without bias and to scrutinise without distortion.

That promise is now under intense scrutiny following revelations that a Panorama documentary edited Donald Trump’s January 6 speech in a way critics claim was misleading.

The documentary reportedly cut a section of Trump’s speech urging peaceful protest, leaving viewers with an impression that he incited violence.

The fallout is two senior resignations, Trump’s $1 billion legal threat, and the integrity of one of the UK’s most prominent news and media brands being globally called into question.

It has made me think about editorial integrity and journalistic bias.

We are in an era of misinformation and deepfakes.

But unlike in the theatre, these illusions are not art; they are weapons.

They distort public understanding and destroy trust.

Bias, whether intentional or unconscious, can significantly distort narratives by shaping what information is highlighted, omitted, or framed in a particular way.

We need only look back at coverage of the statement released by Seagull Theatre in Lowestoft last week for an example of that and my heart goes out to colleagues at Seagull who do amazing work in and for Lowestoft and don’t deserve to be used in that way.

Words are never neutral.

Headlines, captions, and even image choices carry inference.

A single adjective can tilt perception; a cropped photo can imply exclusion or blame.

In theatre, such choices are deliberate and celebrated.

In journalism, they must be scrutinised because language shapes reality for readers who trust it as truth.

Clickbait is another problem.

It is often designed to provoke curiosity or outrage.

We frequently skim headlines without engaging with the full story, meaning the framing becomes the truth for many.

I find it a matter of outrage that some online publications keep the story content behind a paywall but allow open commentary and free access to anyone to read these often uninformed comments.

It is beyond reprehensible and downright dangerous.

When the goal is to go viral rather than be accurate, the very institution tasked with safeguarding truth becomes the agent manipulating it.

Such editorial choices are hugely significant.

They shape narratives, influence public opinion, and, in the high-profile case of the BBC, risk reinforcing political divides.

What should we learn from all this?

Context matters.

Editing is inherent to storytelling, but when context alters meaning, it crosses an ethical line.

Journalists must resist the temptation to simplify complex realities for narrative impact, especially when those realities are politically charged.

In theatre, the playwright and director shape the narrative, deciding what the audience sees and hears.

Their creative choices are transparent.

We know it’s make-believe and we embrace it.

Journalism, however, operates under a different contract: its editors and producers wield similar power, but under the expectation of neutrality.

Strong governance and editorial independence keep journalism separate from the ultimate public theatre that is party politicking.

Last week Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy warned that political appointments to boards, such as those at the BBC, can damage confidence in impartiality.

Who holds the pen matters.

Every cut, every headline, every choice of source is an act of interpretation.

When those decisions are influenced by unconscious bias, commercial pressure, or political appointments, the story ceases to be a record of truth and becomes something else: a performance masquerading as fact.

The consequences of this ripple far beyond one program.

If journalism forgets its role and starts performing, the curtain rises on a tragedy for the audience who depend on it for truth.

Stephen Crocker is Chief Executive and Creative Director at Norwich Theatre.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos