Attleborough meeting descends into Agatha Christie whodunnit

7
Skip to next photo
1/1
Show caption
1/1
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

It was a scene that would make a fitting denouement for an Agatha Christie whodunnit.

With all 14 of his former colleagues on Attleborough Town Council assembled and attentive before him, Nigel Thwaites delivered his accusation with a dramatic flourish.

"Someone around this table lied to all of you," he said.

Mr Thwaites - who stepped down from the authority last month - delivered his chilling denunciation as he returned to its first meeting since his resignation to ask a question as a member of the public.

His apparent aim was to unmask the culprit he believed had leaked confidential information from previous meetings, an issue which had caused him to resign in protest.

The scene was akin to an Agatha Christie novelAgatha Christie is famous for her detective novels (Image: PA) "Last month, I stood down from this council on personal grounds, of integrity," he told the assembled members.

"Someone around this table leaked confidential information.

"Then, when they were challenged, someone around this table lied to all of you and didn't step down.

"What are you doing about it? That one person has destroyed the trust that I had in this council."

Actors in Agatha Christie's Murder on the Orient ExpressActors in Agatha Christie's Murder on the Orient Express (Image: Bettmann Archive) Like the most skilled of sleuths, Mr Thwaites then toyed with his captive audience.

"It doesn't take a genius to figure out who it would be," he added.

Alas for onlookers and fans of whodunnits, Mr Thwaites then left the gallery in suspense, returning to his seat without revealing the identity of the accused.

It was left to Andrew Westby, the town mayor, to respond, saying, in the best traditions of baffled witnesses: "I'm not sure what we can do, to be perfectly honest."

Another councillor, Taila Taylor, suggested a formal complaint could be made to the monitoring officer at Breckland Council, but said councillors would have a "very difficult time" proving who the culprit was.

The recent meeting of Attleborough Town CouncilThe recent meeting of Attleborough Town Council (Image: Newsquest) The strange scenes, at a meeting on Monday night, are the latest in a series of bizarre episodes in which Attleborough Town Council has been embroiled in recent months. 

The authority has been in the headlines as a result of an extraordinary feud with locals in the town, who have criticised a series of unpopular decisions.

They are also angry at the handling of a scandal involving one of its members who has been charged with breaking the window of a shop in the town centre.

Its meetings have lately descended into shouting, insults and accusations flung between councillors and locals, who Mr Thwaites believes are being leaked sensitive information.

At a recent meeting, the clerk Sharon Smyth told all councillors to put their phones in the town hall kitchen because of suspicions one of them had been bugging confidential parts of council meetings, which take place after the public are asked to leave.

Mr Thwaites, who became a councillor, left that meeting and the council after the discussion about removing mobile phones, apparently in annoyance at the suspected breach. 

READ MORE: Locals win battle to stop business expanding on village site

Nigel Thwaites addresses the councilNigel Thwaites addresses the council (Image: Newsquest)

'BATTLEBOROUGH'

The recent tensions between locals and the council have seen the town nicknamed 'Aggroborough' and 'Battleborough'.

They have reached a boiling point at recent meetings, with discussions descending into heckling and calls for resignations.

Attleborough Town HallAttleborough Town Hall (Image: Denise Bradley) Members of the public have been angered by a number of local issues as well as the prosecution of Stephen Fraser, a councillor who was recently charged with criminal damage.

Mr Fraser, who also sits on Breckland Council, was arrested after the window of Richard Allington Kitchens in the town centre was found smashed in April.

A CCTV recording later emerged showing follow councillor Taila Taylor at the scene of the incident.

Stephen FraserStephen Fraser (Image: Stephen Fraser/Facebook) She is not facing any police action but members of the public have questioned why she did not report the matter at the time. She has said she did not witness any damage being caused.

Tensions between the town and the council then flared further following a controversial agreement later that month to fund therapy for any councillors who felt they needed it. 

There has also been criticism of councillors over non-council activities, including their business dealings.

READ MORE: Council told it is 'putting dagger through heart of community' with demolition bid

Conservative MP George Freeman with members of Attleborough Town CouncilConservative MP George Freeman with members of Attleborough Town Council (Image: Facebook) Several social media pages have been set up to lambast the authority for what critics say is its reluctance to address complaints, with sites showing cartoon depictions of some members.

However, the councillors themselves argue they are being unfairly targeted in what they describe as a "campaign of hate" and have taken on their critics.

During a recent meeting, Ms Smyth said councillors had experienced members of the public banging on their windows and doors, had their car headlights smashed, and claimed Taila Taylor had been "bitten" by a customer at the pub her family runs. 

She also said Mr Fraser had been called a "w****r" and "c**t" in the street, slapped in the face, and had the bolts removed from his car wheels.

But the latest meeting of Attleborough Town Council seemed to suggest tensions are abating, with far fewer voices raised and discussions more focussed than in recent weeks.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos