Only three at City Hall know Morrison pay-out figure
Just three people at City Hall know how much Norwich City Council paid out to head off a High Court battle with Morrison, it has emerged, with the authority's chief executive not among them.
The revelation came to light as city councillors questioned why they were not allowed to know the details of the financial settlement the council reached with the company.
Members of the city council's audit committee queried how they could carry out democratic checks and balances without knowing the amount and council officers revealed the number of people at City Hall who knew was so small that even chief executive Laura McGillivray was not privy to the sum.
The city council reached the settlement with Morrison, the parent company of former city council contractor CityCare in April, but the figure has never been revealed.
Before the settlement was reached it looked as if Morrison, which had successfully obtained an injunction to prevent the city council awarding a �17.5m contract to maintain 17,000 council homes to Connaught Partnerships, would take the council to a potentially costly High Court showdown.
You may also want to watch:
The issue was raised as the city council's audit committee discussed the annual governance report by local government watchdogs The Audit Commission.
James Wright, Liberal Democrat councillor for Eaton, was told by deputy chief executive Bridget Buttinger that the figure was confidential and could not be shared.
- 1 Norfolk wakes up to empty pumps – despite assurances of ‘ample fuel stocks’
- 2 Huge seaside home with indoor pool for sale for £600,000
- 3 Man dies in hospital after fight near Norfolk pub
- 4 The Bill star reveals he has moved to Norfolk and why he loves it
- 5 Why has a golden dome appeared in this Norfolk town?
- 6 Delays on roads as petrol queues continue
- 7 Dramatic pictures as huge barn fire breaks out near coast
- 8 Queues form at Norfolk petrol stations - despite reassurances over stock
- 9 Q&A: All you need to know about fuel shortages
- 10 A11 to undergo 18 months of roadworks
He said: 'We, as members looking at the audit of the council's finances, surely should have an understanding of it. As members with responsibility for checks and balances I feel we ought to know.' Mrs Buttinger said: 'One of the terms of the agreement was absolute confidentiality. There's a very small number of people at the council who know. It's not a sum we can discuss. It would be breaking the terms of the confidentiality agreement.'
Stephen Little, chair of the committee and Green councillor for Town Close ward, said: 'We have been told that even the chief executive doesn't know, which was very surprising to me.' He added that he was concerned that such confidentiality agreements made it difficult for public money to be accountable.
Mrs Buttinger confirmed Mrs McGillivray was not aware of the sum and said there were 'probably three people' at City Hall who did know.
Although she did not reveal who they were, she said the number had been kept low because of the 'high risk' to the council if the confidentiality agreement was breached.
She said the district auditor Rob Murray had been made aware, for the purposes of carrying out his audit of the council's finances, what the sum was and had not raised the figure as a concern.
Mr Murray told the committee: 'If I thought the arrangement was inappropriate I would be reporting it to this committee.'
Alan Waters, cabinet member for resources, performance and shared services, was not able to attend yesterday's meeting, but said in a statment that he hoped the district auditor's comments on the pay-out and his verdict that the subsequent arrangements to relet contracts were 'adequate' would 'dispel any doubts' about the council's handling of the issue.