Leader defends himself over claims he ‘misled’ council

A council leader was questioned on whether he had misled the authority over the appointment of a for

A council leader was questioned on whether he had misled the authority over the appointment of a former chief executive. Pictured, Elizabeth House in Dereham. Photo: Ian Burt - Credit: IAN BURT

A council leader was questioned on whether he had “misled” the authority over the appointment of a former chief executive at an organisation with a “significant bullying problem” to a senior job.

Timothy Birt, Green Party councillor for Saham Toney. Pic: Green Party.

Timothy Birt, Green Party councillor for Saham Toney. Pic: Green Party. - Credit: Green Party

Breckland Council appointed the ex-West Sussex County Council chief executive Nathan Elvery as its temporary head of paid service last month.

Mr Elvery left the Sussex authority in November last year after a report found “systemic failures” in the childrens’ services department and highlighted a “significant bullying problem” at the “very top of the organisation”.

He received a £265,000 payout - the equivalent of six months pay.

READ MORE: Former chief executive at council with ‘significant bullying problem’ given senior Norfolk role

Breckland council leader Sam Chapman-Allen. Photo: Breckland Council

Breckland council leader Sam Chapman-Allen. Photo: Breckland Council - Credit: Archant

During a special full council meeting on Thursday, October 8, the council voted to confirm Mr Elvery’s appointment after being told by council leader Sam Chapman-Allen that he would do “no direct line management”.


You may also want to watch:


But speaking during a meeting on Thursday, November 5, Green Party councillor Timothy Birt questioned Mr Chapman-Allen.

The Saham Toney councillor said: “You claim that the temporary head of paid service would have no line management responsibilities.

Most Read

“But that may not be strictly correct, because the head of paid service is ultimately the person who hires and fires the executives of this council - which surely is a line management responsibility.

“I wonder whether you may have slightly misled this council at that October 8 meeting?”

But the Conservative council leader defended his remarks and Mr Elvery’s appointment.

READ MORE: Breckland Council’s chief executive announces plans to step down

He said: “In relation to direct line management responsibilities, I’m afraid you are incorrect.

“It is not the role of the head of paid service or the chief executive to undertake the hiring and firing of chief officers of this council - that falls to a joint appointments panel to make that final decision if we are firing or hiring any of those individuals.

“In relation to other staff within the authority, that goes through the appropriate channels with their line manager and the head of HR supporting them through that process.

“So I am confident that unless anything has changed in the preceding three weeks that the appointment of the head of paid service still has no direct line management responsibilities.”

Mr Birt also queried whether the role must be held by an officer of the council, but was told there was no “advice to the contrary”.

READ MORE: New roles for former council bosses as Norwich City Council takes services in-house

Become a Supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Become a Supporter
Comments powered by Disqus