Why the Chancellor should budget for a Stamp Duty holiday extension

Hand with tree growing from pile of coins, concept for business, innovation, growth and money

Jan Hytch, residential partner at Arnolds Keys, believes Chancellor Rishi Sunak should extend the Stamp Duty holiday in order to mitigate delays presented by Covid-19. - Credit: Getty Images/iStockphoto

Rishi Sunak is probably one of the few politicians whose reputation has not been tarnished by the Covid crisis.

It’s surprising to realise that he has only been Chancellor for 12 months; during that time he has delivered just one full-blown Budget, but more than a dozen other major economic announcements.

As the positive effects of the vaccination programme start to kick in, and a gradual easing of lockdown at last seems a realistic possibility, his second Budget, to be delivered on 3rd March, is one of the most important in many years. He is faced with the significant challenge of maintaining the economic stimuli necessary to avoid a lasting slump, while planning to get Britain’s battered fiscal position back on track.

He has many competing demands, but nevertheless one of the most important decisions he has to take is on the thorny question of Stamp Duty Land tax (SDLT).

Jan Hytch, partner at Arnolds Keys and chairwoman of the NDAEA, Norwich & District Association of Es

Jan Hytch, partner at Arnolds Keys and chair of the NDAEA, Norwich & District Association of Estate Agents - Credit: Arnolds Keys

The current stamp duty ‘holiday’ means that anyone completing a house purchase before 31st March will pay no SDLT on the first £500,000; after this date we revert to the former threshold scale, with the tax becoming payable on everything over the first £125,000, which in many parts of the country means SDLT is payable on every property transaction.

Bear in mind your average first time buyer has already ploughed their hard-earned (and taxed) income into saving for a deposit (in a taxed savings account), and so could justifiably ask why they should pay tax a third time for the right to own their home.

Along with others, I’ve been giving testimony to the snappily-named Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government on the effect of SDLT on the market, and specifically on the impact of the stamp duty holiday and the likely result of the ‘cliff-edge’ end to the holiday on 31st March.

Businessman and wooden blocks with the word Stamp duty and house. Taxes assessed during the transfer

After March 31, SDLT will be payable on everything over the first £125,000 of a property's price - Credit: Getty Images/iStockphoto

Most Read

Instead of that cut-off date being for completions, it would make more sense to say instead that the earlier stage of exchange of contracts need to happen before this date, but then give people up to three months to complete their purchase. This would mitigate against delays such as heavy snow stalling surveys, a buyer or seller having to self-isolate during the process, or even the whole chain missing out on the completion deadline just because one removal van driver has to suddenly self-isolate on moving day.

Longer term, the SDLT zero rate threshold should be raised to a more realistic £350,000 to help first time buyers and ‘second steppers’. In addition, the Chancellor should remove stamp duty for downsizers, or at least offer SDLT incentives for them to move, so that older homeowners who want to downsize into a smaller home could be encouraged through a stamp duty exemption.

This would be a popular move for many in Norfolk, which naturally attracts an older demographic, and it would have the effect of leaving downsizers with more money in their pockets, bring more family homes to the market to meet the increasing demand - and take some of the heat out of disproportionately rising prices for three and four bedroom detached homes, to make them more affordable for families.

Jan Hÿtch is residential partner at Arnolds Keys.