In search of a great British breakfast... in secret

PUBLISHED: 09:37 13 January 2015 | UPDATED: 10:06 13 January 2015

The Fry Up Inspector, the anonymous blogger who has reviewed more than 300 fry-ups in Norwich and across the country, at Pandora's Kitchen which has the official Fry Up Inspector Breakfast on its menu.
Picture by SIMON FINLAY.

The Fry Up Inspector, the anonymous blogger who has reviewed more than 300 fry-ups in Norwich and across the country, at Pandora's Kitchen which has the official Fry Up Inspector Breakfast on its menu. Picture by SIMON FINLAY.

Archant Norfolk.

He’s a self-appointed taste tester on the hunt for the perfect belly-busting breakfast, a man who truly knows his eggs from his bacon. In the run up to National Breakfast Week which begins on January 25, STACIA BRIGGS finds out why grease is the word for the mystery Fry-Up Inspector.

The Fry Up Inspector, the anonymous blogger who has reviewed more than 300 fry-ups in Norwich and across the country, at Pandora's Kitchen which has the official Fry Up Inspector Breakfast on its menu.
Picture by SIMON FINLAY.The Fry Up Inspector, the anonymous blogger who has reviewed more than 300 fry-ups in Norwich and across the country, at Pandora's Kitchen which has the official Fry Up Inspector Breakfast on its menu. Picture by SIMON FINLAY.

It’s a proud tradition that is as English as Big Ben, black taxis, rainclouds and queuing, but considerably more calorific than them all.

The full English Breakfast, containing the so-called “magic nine” of eggs, bacon, sausage, black pudding, tomatoes, mushrooms, baked beans, a form of potato-based product and a form of bread-based product, has been a national institution since the 1800s.

In 215 years, the fry-up has made the move from mansion to greasy spoon and from landed gentry to ordinary Joe, casting off ‘brain cakes’ and ‘devilled bones’ along the way.

In 1840, a ‘full English’ might have included baked halibut steaks, fried whiting, pheasant legs, collared tongue, kidneys on toast, sausages with fried bread, pig’s cheek and Melton pork pie.

Extracts from the 9/10 review of The House Café, in St Benedict’s Street, Norwich

-Service – The staff here were really friendly and efficient giving a choice of how I wanted my eggs cooked and were happy to explain what the veggie breakfast consisted of. They took our order and brought the hot drinks and food over when it was ready. Once the food had arrived they checked to see if any sauces were required. 9/10

-Contents - 3 chipolata sausages, 2 bacon, fried egg, 2 hash browns, grilled tomato, portobello mushroom, beans and toasted ciabatta & butter. 8/10

-Presentation - The food looked beautifully cooked and filled the plate nicely. The person that had cooked it so nicely clearly understood the importance of nice presentation. I wanted to put the beans onto a slice of the toasted ciabatta and I was able to easily pour them on from the pot they were served in. 9/10

-The food - Fantastic tasting and nicely cooked chipolatas and bacon supplied by Frank Spurgeon (local butcher), An almost perfect fried egg and nice and crispy hash browns. The juicy portobello mushroom was full of flavour and the tomato was incredibly nice. The beans were piping hot and went perfectly with quite possibly the nicest homemade ciabatta I have ever tasted! 10/10

-Value for money - The food was amazing and there was plenty of it, the toasted ciabatta and butter is included in the price so you will not leave feeling hungry. It was the best £7.45 I have spent in a long time. 9/10

Twenty years later, Mrs Beeton suggested: “Boiled fish, such as mackerel, whiting, herrings, dried haddocks, mutton chops and rump steaks, broiled sheep’s kidneys, kidneys a la maitre d’hotel, plain rashers of bacon, bacon and poached eggs, ham and poached eggs, omelettes, plain boiled eggs, oeufs-au-plat, poached eggs on toast, muffins, toast, marmalade, butter.”

And four years later, Georgina Hill’s The Breakfast Book listed some more fried breakfast treats: anchovies, bloaters, brain cakes, caviar, cold tongue, devilled bones and dried sprats.

This list alone seems justification for the fact that I have never had a fried breakfast in all my days.

The Fry-Up Inspector – who must remain nameless in order to protect, well, him – has, however, eaten my share of fried breakfasts, more than 300 in the past few years, and knows exactly what makes the perfect Full English.

Breakfast at NNUH

The Norfolk and Norwich University Hospital will be celebrating National Breakfast Week from January 26-31 with a range of tempting options in its cafés and restaurants.

In addition to offering patients, staff and visitors useful facts about breakfast and the health benefits of eating up to 35 per cent of your daily allowance of calories in the morning, the SERCO catering team will be offering new dishes such as smoked haddock with spinach and poached eggs, granola with yoghurt and honey, kippers with lemon, brown bread and butter and a selection of new pastries. The NNUH also has its own fry-up: five items cost £3.85.

‘All in the eggs’

Indeed, his approved fry-up, which bears his name – The Fry-Up Inspector’s Breakfast, £9.95, available from Pandora’s Kitchen on London Street in Norwich – has just been named one of Esquire magazine’s top 25 breakfasts in the UK (although it notes, primly, “not for daily consumption”).

“You can normally tell if a breakfast is going to be a good one by the eggs,” notes the Inspector, who is in his 40s, works in Norwich and bears the lithe figure of one who breakfasts like a king just once a week rather than every day, “if the eggs are well-cooked, there’s a good chance the rest of the breakfast will be too. It’s amazing how many places can’t even cook an egg!

“I prefer people not to know who I am because I want the reviews to be impartial. Some people do know who I am now and it does change the way you’re treated – staff make a bit more effort and that’s not what I want. I want to review the experience that everyone gets, whoever they are.”

For the past two-and-a-half years, the Fry-Up Inspector has been searching across the UK – although mainly in Norwich on the basis he lives here – for the perfect full English breakfast, handing out accolades and criticisms along the way.

Those that attain the highest plaudits of 8.5 out of 10 or higher are awarded Inspector Recommended stickers which they can display like Michelin stars, those that fail the grade must be prepared to be named and shamed on his blog,

He has rated and reviewed more than 300 breakfasts based on first impressions, service, ingredients, presentation, taste and value and has attracted an online audience of hundreds of thousands, having started his quest for the perfect breakfast after a particularly grim early morning experience at a chain hotel.

‘The weekend has started’

The Inspector has eaten across Norfolk, in London, Northampton, Cambridge, Ipswich, Peterborough, Nottingham, Brighton and Bristol, in Paris, New York, Brussels and in Spain. He has even reviewed mid-air, on aeroplane flights.

“I don’t really remember fry-ups from home, but when I lived at the YMCA in the 1980s, there’d be a fry-up every morning. It was a real treat and it set you up for the day. But when I left, I’d had enough fried breakfasts for a while and I went off them. They later became a hangover antidote after I’d gone out!” he laughed.

“Fry-ups for me mean the weekend has started – they’re a treat. For it to be a great breakfast, the meat has to be high quality, the egg needs to have a runny yolk but the white has to be cooked, the tomatoes need flavour – from a can if needs be – I love a bit of fried bread and mushrooms, baked beans need to be there to stop any dryness and there definitely, definitely shouldn’t be any chips. Chips aren’t for breakfast.”

The Inspector’s wife accompanies him on his reviews and, having recently become vegetarian, is able to give him a meat-avoider’s mini-review on the fry-up options for those who prefer Quorn to flesh. Brilliantly, the pair had a fry-up themed wedding reception, complete with a cake decorated in icing sugar sausages.

“I like to go into as much detail as possible because I know that lots of people like to go out for breakfast and it’s nice to offer them an informed guide that let’s them know the full story,” he said. “A great fried-breakfast can be served anywhere – in a greasy spoon café or in a posh restaurant. It’s about the vibe of the place, the service, the ingredients and the whole experience. I could buy nice ingredients myself and cook them at home, but what I’m looking for is more than that.”

There are more than a dozen establishments in Norwich that the Inspector has awarded a coveted sticker to although his favourite fry-up that he’s reviewed so far is out of the city, at E Pellicci in Bethnal Green, which received a hard-to-beat 9.5 out of 10 and “ticks all the right boxes in relation to what matters on my search for the perfect fry-up”.

With a perfect 10 yet to grace the leader board, the quest to find the ultimate fry-up continues. “I still enjoy a good fried breakfast even after eating so many. I don’t get bored of them and in fact it’s the only time in the week when I actually eat breakfast at all – one day, maybe I will find the perfect breakfast. In the meantime, I’ll enjoy the search.”

If you value what this story gives you, please consider supporting the Eastern Daily Press. Click the link in the orange box above for details.

Become a supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Latest from the Eastern Daily Press