Shadow Health Secretary Andy Burnham addressing a public meeting in the Curve, at the Forum, Norwich. Photo: Steve Adams
By KIM BRISCOE, Health correspondent
Thursday, January 26, 2012
7:41 PM
Labour’s shadow health team has warned that the Government’s controversial reforms could cost Norfolk and Waveney nearly £62m at a time when the already cash-strapped health service can ill afford the cost of reorganisation.
A. We’ve said we’re going to have to be realistic because of the way the government has failed to bring growth to the economy. Everyone has to be honest about that and face up to that – there’s a stand off between pay and jobs.
What I would preserve is national pay arrangements. They are one of the essential principles of the NHS.
Shadow health secretary Andy Burnham visited Norwich to drum up support for a campaign urging the Coalition to axe its unpopular Health and Social Care Bill.
The former health secretary told health professionals and members of Unison and the Labour Party at a question and answer session at The Forum that the proposed legislation was “the greatest threat to the NHS in it’s 63-year history”.
He called upon activists to follow the lead of Norwich City director Stephen Fry, who yesterday urged his nearly 4m followers on social networking website Twitter to sign up to the “Drop the Bill” e-petition online.
So far nearly 40,000 people have signed up to the e-petition and while Mr Burnham said many good local campaigns had been run along similar lines, he was trying to bring all the different opposition groups together to give a national focus and a national voice to show the Coalition the true extent of the unpopularity of the reforms.
A. I was health secretary when I set the £20bn efficiency challenge for the NHS. I’ve never shirked that, it’s a very difficult thing to do. The only way the NHS has a hope of doing it is if it has stability.
What had to be done is difficult decisions around reform of services – treating less people in hospital and more people at home. That’s the kind of change the NHS needs to get on with.
It’s (the Bill) a huge distraction to the bigger challenge of helping the NHS rise to the efficiency challenge rather than just making further cuts to services.
He was joined by shadow health ministers Jamie Reed and Diane Abbott, who took questions about Labour’s policies on health and said that while the Bill purported to be giving more power to clinicians, in their view it was a blatant attempt to open up the NHS to privatisation.
Mr Burnham, who also took the time to visit Hellesdon Hospital on his trip to the city, said the private sector still had role to play within a planned system, but to open up the NHS to a market-based system which is subject to commercial contracts was unacceptable.
He said: “That’s a fundamental break with 63 years of NHS history. It’s a ‘genie out of the bottle’ moment where the NHS as we know it would come to an end.”
Chris Francis, a Norwich GP who is co-chairman of the Norwich Clinical Commissioning Group, asked what was Labour’s ‘plan B’.
A. No and overwhelmingly professionals are now telling him he’s got it wrong and he needs to listen. 98pc of GPs are opposed to the government’s plans. If he was to ask 100 GPs 98 would say the same. This bill is bad for the NHS. He made great play at the start of his address about empowering professionals but he needs to put his money where his mouth is now and drop the bill.
Mr Burnham said: “Plan B right now, if the Bill was dropped, would be to ask your emerging team to work with the other clinical commissioning groups to get a single leadership which would work under the same area as the old PCT. I think that saves money, cuts disruption but delivers clinical commissioning.”
The issue of the government refusing to publish its risk register, which outlines all the possible risks as a result of the NHS reforms, was also discussed, with Mr Burnham saying he hoped it would finally be made public following an information tribunal in early March.
He revealed that he would be giving a key speech on mental health next week, and that he was also in the process of forming Labour’s health policy for the next election, with better integration of mental health, physical health and social care a priority.
To sign the e-petition, log on to http://bit.ly/tMkKz1.
Supporters of Scottish champions Celtic are in Norwich ahead of the Adam Drury testimonial game tonight.
2 comments
Andy Burnham is working so hard at this and deserves credit for his efforts.Cameron is using the NHS as a vehicle to channel tax payer's money through the NHS and to his friends in big business, proving two things 1) the Tories are completely in the pockets of the banks and big business 2) you can't trust the Tories with the NHS. Who would have thought though that Norman Lamb and Simon Wright would be their partners in crime?
Report this comment
Sam Rushworth
Thursday, January 26, 2012
Er...if this is an unbiased piece of journalism, should you really be including a reference to where the e petition can be signed? Not sure you should be...
Report this comment
merrydancer
Thursday, January 26, 2012