Flood defence spending decisions must give East Anglian farm land more value

Flood season in the Waveney Valley between Beccles and Bungay.; Photo: Andy Darnell

Flood season in the Waveney Valley between Beccles and Bungay.; Photo: Andy Darnell

Archant © 2011

Flood defence spending fails to recognise the importance and value of farm land, an influential committee of MPs has said in a far reaching report following the winter floods.

The Environment, Food and Rural Affairs commons select committee has called for the Government to revisit its policy on how it hands out cash for flood defences to take more account of the “economic and social value of agricultural land”.

The report also said that funding for clearing rivers, routine dredging and maintaining existing flood defences was at a “bare minimum”.

While the committee commended the relief effort for the floods, which saw 7,000 properties flooded as the UK was hit by repeated storms and the wettest winter on record, they said investment in flood prevention was preferable to spending on clean-up. Work to shore up East Anglia’s battered coastline defences – which will leave a £10m dent in Environment Agency coffers – will be completed in time for winter.

A total of 130 defence repair projects have been earmarked in Norfolk, Suffolk and Essex, but area manager Charles Beardall insists work will be done in time for the onset of any storms this winter.

National Farmers’ Union East Anglia environment adviser Rob Wise said 2,700 hectares of farmland was flooded as a result of December’s east coast tidal surge, and many sea defences were breached.

“As the committee says, the economic and social value of farming and agricultural land must be recognised to ensure there is sufficient investment in maintenance work. With 350,000 hectares of prime farmland in the Fens alone at risk of flooding, plus further land alone the coast, our defences must be adequately maintained.

He urged the government to accept the committee’s recommendations, adding: “The evidence is clear. Now it’s time to act”.

The committee also highlighted that £130 million of money described as extra cash had, in fact, been “reallocated” from elsewhere in Defra’s budget.

Shadow environment secretary Maria Eagle said: “In February, David Cameron said ‘money was no object’ when it came to flood defence funding, yet today the select committee says that the funding the Government describe as additional is actually only reallocated. David Cameron’s ‘promise’ has, predictably, proved totally false.”

Ms Eagle added: “The Tory-led Government’s response to the winter floods was slow and chaotic. Ministers cut the funding Labour provided in government and the select committee says they are now unable to deal with the long-term flood risk.”

What do you think? Email, including your full name and address.

Comment – Page 26

1 comment

  • Balance is everything. We have seen EDP hysteria about a few old chalets which should not have been occupied all year round to start with and calls to protect a few caravan sites from the sea-again where they should have been moved to an inland store in winter. Meanwhile Defra and English Nature preside over schemes to allow land worth up to £10K an acre to reflood-land which we may need even more to feed ourselves in the future. The long term value of for instance, the high grade land at Happisburgh or Horsey has to be weighed against the long term cost and difficulty of protection. The Guardian will be blaming the Tories for the lack of dredging of the rivers and the part this played in flooding. but this is all the fault of long term policy at the Environment Agency-policy formed under Labour's bash the rural businesses and country people regime and under the influence of theoretical enviromentalists and charities like the RSPB . Drainage boards have been complaining to the EA for years about the lack of river maintenance, their excuse was it is not natural and will just need doing again-well duh- few of the rivers are completely natural in all their reaches now, so they have to be maintained.

    Report this comment

    Daisy Roots

    Tuesday, June 17, 2014

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site


Most Read

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most Commented

Latest from the EDP

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 12°C

min temp: 7°C

Listen to the latest weather forecast

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the EDP
digital edition