Pressure mounts for Eric Pickles to call-in Norfolk County Council’s King’s Lynn incinerator decision

PUBLISHED: 06:30 30 June 2012 | UPDATED: 09:27 30 June 2012

The proposed Incinerator site at Saddlebow, King's Lynn. Picture: Ian Burt

The proposed Incinerator site at Saddlebow, King's Lynn. Picture: Ian Burt

Archant © 2012

Anti-incinerator campaigners have said it is essential that the government has the final say on the King’s Lynn incinerator, after Norfolk County Council decided to approve plans for the plant.

At a meeting which lasted for more than seven hours, members of the county council’s planning regulatory committee yesterday voted to grant planning permission for the Willows Power and Recycling Centre at Saddlebow.

Because of an intervention by communities secretary Eric Pickles, a decision notice for the plant cannot be issued until his department has decided whether to ‘call in’ the matter.

And that is exactly what campaigners against the incinerator, which Norfolk County Council’s controlling Conservative cabinet has said is vital to deal with the county’s waste, say must now happen after yesterday’s decision.

Objectors told the meeting that the plant goes against planning policy, that peer-reviewed studies show a link between incinerators and poor health, the localism agenda is being ignored, people would rather see alternative technologies used, the site is in a flood risk area and, having already agreed to award the contract, the council’s own planning committee could not be trusted to fairly and objectively consider the application.

However, councillors voted by nine votes to four, with two abstaining, to grant permission for the incinerator, which would be run by Anglo-US consortium Cory Wheelabrator.

Elizabeth Truss, South West Norfolk MP, who has campaigned against the incinerator, said pressure was mounting on Mr Pickles to have the final say on the scheme.

She said: “I think it was encouraging that Eric Pickles specifically mentioned the fact that all nine MPs have asked for it to be called in.

“I cannot see why he would have done that if he was no thinking about calling it in. I have spoken to Mr Pickles this week and will put the point across to Bob Neil [parliamentary under secretary of state] when I see him next week. It’s time to keep up the pressure.”

Campaigner Michael de Whalley said Mr Pickles should call in the decision to give people confidence in the final decision.

He said: “I think we gave the community as good a representation as we possibly could. It’s now for the secretary of state to decide if it’s going to be approved or called in.

“That will have as long as it needs to discuss the agreement and we will have a discussion. The general public will have confidence in this decision. If we have no confidence it’s a charade.”

Andrew Boswell, Green Party spokesman for environment, transport and development said: “It is no surprise that the application has been approved when the planning committee is largely made up of the ruling Conservative group and that group has wanted the incinerator all along.

“The meeting produced a catalogue of uncertainties and unanswered questions in the application. These include the air quality model and carbon emission footprint being seriously flawed, the risks to public health and from flooding, and that the incinerator would prevent Norfolk using more innovative waste treatment methods and suppress our recycling rates.

“The government must get to the bottom of these, and it can only do so now by a full call-in.”

An often tense meeting sprang to life when North West Norfolk MP Henry Bellingham urged councillors to “stand up for democracy” by not allowing an incinerator to be built at King’s Lynn.

Ignoring calls from the planning committee chairman John Rogers to stop talking, after going over his allotted time limit, Mr Bellingham had called for the county council to live up to its At Your Service motto.

He said: “One of the lessons of the Arab Spring and events in Europe such as Greece is that you defy democracy at your peril. What will happen is that people will lose trust in you. I ask you today to stand up for democracy.”

But, following the meeting, Graham Plant, cabinet member for planning and transportation, said: “Members of the committee thoroughly examined the application and, after a full and frank debate, accepted officers’ recommendations.

“The committee was satisfied that officers had addressed all relevant considerations and agreed that planning permission should be granted. This is, of course, subject to the Secretary of State’s views.”

Bill Borrett, cabinet member for environment and waste, said he was “relieved” at the decision and said it was “another step on the way”.

He said: “I believe that this proposal has been subjected to the most intensive scrutiny, by the planning process, the public, the Environment Agency and DEFRA, which has approved the largest grant Norfolk has received for a single project.

“I have been very keen that we do everything by the book, so I welcome the secretary of state’s interest.”

Speaking after the meeting, John Bolden, Cory’s director of planning and communications, said: “We are very pleased.

“We’ve been working for a very long time on the proposal doing all the work for the environmental assessments for some 21 months.

“We’ve always been very confident in the work we have been doing to satisfy the statutory authorities and bodies.

“In terms of the way forward, we have to wait for the secretary of state. If he decides not to call it in we will get planning permission from Norfolk County Council.

“If he decides he does call it in, we go through the whole public inquiry process.

“On the assumption we get permission and make the next step forward, we want to work with the local community.”

Mr Bolden said he would like to create a committee involving community representatives to keep them informed about what is happening with the project.

Related articles


  • I nearly fainted at Borretts last words. WE WANT TO WORK WITH THE LOCAL COMMUNITY! Why change the habit of a lifetime Borrett, it would certainly be a first. The trouble is I do not know anyone who would want to be seen talking to you!

    Report this comment

    Joy, King's Lynn

    Saturday, June 30, 2012

  • They won't get anything until the cheque for £20m has been cashed, so there's incentive for it being pushed so hard. The biggest pay outs only come once it's built, that's how it works in the US - $1million for the 3 main people smoothing it through in Boston and California seems to be the going rate.

    Report this comment

    Honest John

    Saturday, June 30, 2012

  • Accepted officers’ recommendations. That is the same cop-out G. Plant made over Yarmouth’s Outer Harbour. Why follow Officers advice when 99% of the Electorate don’t want the incinerator. We in Yarmouth had a similar problem, and five years after the contracts were signed we find a Bonus of £25,000.00 was paid to an Officer that recommended the outer harbour deal to the Borough Councilors. Some of these same councilors are the ones that in a FOI reply stated “we followed officers recommendations”! One would ask, “are any bonuses being paid to NCC officers to finalize the contract”?

    Report this comment

    John L Cooper

    Saturday, June 30, 2012

  • I imagine that Cllr Derrick Murphy will now be writing pleading letters on a daily basis to Eric Pickles, as he was at the beginning of the year to Caroline Spelman. If you want to check this out, simply make an FOIA requesr to NCC.

    Report this comment

    John Martin

    Sunday, July 1, 2012

  • This planning meeting was to teach West Norfolk Council, MPs and residents a lesson. Problem is it may backfire not only the incinerator to be called in but the integrity of County Hall officials.

    Report this comment


    Saturday, June 30, 2012

  • The only committee that Mr Bolden is welcome to form involves his lips and my backside....... maybe he'd like to set one up with residents from the east of the county since he's already canvassed so many of them?

    Report this comment

    User Removed

    Saturday, June 30, 2012

  • Fenscape, I am shocked! is that a hint at the fact that the conservative cllrs from the East of Norfolk seemed to believe every self interested word Mr Boldon said during his many speaches.

    Report this comment

    Joy, King's Lynn

    Saturday, June 30, 2012

  • Mr Bolden why don't you get it we do not want to work with you!!!!

    Report this comment


    Saturday, June 30, 2012

  • I don't know how you could be so unkind to Mr Bolden Mr Scape. He wanders the streets of Britain looking for places to sell his horrible bottom ash trying to kid us all on that it is something we want. Now, here's the choice. You can have a recycled material that you can make posts and tiles and even garden tables and chairs (with no danger to health) or you can have Mr Bolden's bottom ash and also Mr Bolden's top ash with its particulates of cadmium, arsenic and every other nasty you can think of to inhale. Think very carefully before deciding what option you prefer. Oh no, that's right, there's no choice at all. Come and join me in my garden sitting on my recycled chairs. Pimms anyone?

    Report this comment


    Saturday, June 30, 2012

  • The state of county hall has become a sad metaphor for NCC under the Murphy administration. Crumbling, diseased and no longer fit for purpose but being propped up by the Norfolk taxpayer nonetheless....

    Report this comment

    User Removed

    Saturday, June 30, 2012

  • Pathetic wet lettuce by the EDP leader writer wanting this over as soon as possible.Saying Norfolk people are sheep-Horatio Nelson for example-is hardly going to achieve consent.This is such a hot potato for the Tories they will pass it to Pickles who will try to kill it quietly with some soothing words.This is not good enough from the man who brought us "localism".It may need a full independent enquiry as Cllr Nobbs has revealed there is £20 million penalty for turning it down.The worry for the Tories is that it is our money they could end up throwing down the drain.

    Report this comment

    Peter Watson

    Saturday, June 30, 2012

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Most Read

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most Commented

Latest from the EDP

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 10°C

min temp: 5°C

Listen to the latest weather forecast

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the EDP
digital edition