Pupil behaviour problems are ‘widespread’ according to Norfolk and Suffolk UEA study

08:47 05 September 2012

Disruptive pupil behaviour is 'widespread', according to a new UEA research report.

Disruptive pupil behaviour is 'widespread', according to a new UEA research report.

(c) Stockbyte

Pupil behaviour problems are “widespread” according to new research conducted with teachers, pupils and student teachers in Norfolk and Suffolk.

The findings, which come in the week that pupils return to school from the summer holidays, are the result of a 10-year University of East Anglia project which researchers say shows that official conclusions on the standard of behaviour in England’s secondary classrooms underestimate the scale of the problem in many schools.

The research was compiled from four studies, including a survey of 243 PGCE trainee teachers, carried out by Prof Terry Haydn from UEA’s school of Education and Lifelong Learning. The survey found that more than half of student teachers surveyed about their school experiences, either as young professionals or as pupils, said they had often been in lessons where the teacher was not in complete control of the class.

Prof Haydn’s research contrasts with official pronouncements on behaviour standards, for example Ofsted data shows that 99.7 per cent of schools have pupil behaviour which is described by inspectors as at least satisfactory.

Today one union echoed professor Haydn, saying the findings accurately reflected the increasingly difficult job that teachers faced in classrooms.

The research, compiled from four main studies, included interviews with 105 classroom teachers and 13 head teachers from more than 80 schools, carried out in 2006/07.

All 13 heads indicated that pupil behaviour was at least to some extent “an issue” in their schools. While in some schools it was not seen as a major problem, many teachers reported that at least some of their classes “required careful handling” to keep fully under control. Comments from teachers included: “I am very experienced and am generally accepted by the staff as someone who is good at dealing with the kids but I am finding it really difficult to cope with the number of pupils who are really serious cases, who are off the scale in terms of their behaviour.”

Prof Haydn said: “It should be stressed that there are many schools in the UK where the lower levels of the behaviour scale never occur. But the outcomes of the surveys I have undertaken over the past decade suggest that there would appear to be few schools in the UK where there are no deficits in the working atmosphere in classrooms.

“A second important point to note is that there would appear to be massive variations, both between schools and within individual schools, in terms of the behaviour levels prevailing. In-school variation is part of the problem. There is an important difference between classrooms in which the working atmosphere is ‘satisfactory’, and a classroom climate that is perfectly conducive to learning, in terms of the impact on pupil attainment.”

Prof Haydn said policy-makers should not claim that there are easy fixes or suggest that poor pupil behaviour is simply due to poor teaching or bad schools. At least part of the problem lay in factors outside schools and classrooms.

Colin Collis, Norfolk branch secretary for the NASUWT teaching union, said it could take just one or two badly behaved pupils to significantly disrupt a good working atmosphere in a classroom, and various factors such as gender, parental attitude, children’s attitude to learning and even the curriculum played a part in whether a class was well-behaved or not.

He said: “In quite a few places petty, low level disruption is harming a good working atmosphere.”


  • This comes as no surprise to many I would suspect, professionals and parents and pupils. Of course some institutions do not have good behaviour management policies in place but most do. And of course there was always the pupil in each class presenting problems and tricky combinations of pupils that made nightmares of certain classes.My observation is that the problem has been worsening steadily for several decades and now with high levels of inclusion of those with behavioural problems can only be worse. I have my own theory that part of the problem rests with the trend in how some male children are treated by their parents-there seems to have been a shift in expectations, from expecting boys to be energetic but to know when to behave, sit still and study and taking for granted that they would do as told, to a situation now when male toddlers are encouraged to ramp about, rarely taught how to exercise any self control and concentration and grow up with their misbehaviour and poor performance at school excused by the new laddism trend of boys will be boys and they can't help it. To read of child psychologists ( usually young ones) finding some justification or other for this is abhorrent,if boys of my generation were capable of behaving and tackling their studies properly so should the current crop. Lazy parenting is also at fault, it is harder work to teach a child to behave properly than to yell at it. I also believe that looking at secondary schools is too late-we need to see what infant schools are doing and especially research into the possible effects of poor nursery schooling is urgently needed. The rise in misbehaviour seems to coincide with the rise in full time child care and particularly nursery attendance and I think we need to know if it is there that something is going wrong, if children are entering infant schools with plenty of confidence but with attitudes not compatible with good classroom behaviour.

    Report this comment

    Daisy Roots

    Wednesday, September 5, 2012

  • I know it's true as I have seen it, but using student teachers as spies is below the belt

    Report this comment

    Jacob Burns

    Wednesday, September 5, 2012

  • UEA Research ?. Ha. Could have told them it was wide spread, and the so called teachers and head teachers all live in self denial that it is happening in their school!. Yet another waste of money on useless research from the UEA.

    Report this comment


    Wednesday, September 5, 2012

  • Research assistants might be nearer the mark-one assumes the right to report on what they experience in the classroom is part and parcel of the PGCE teaching practice.

    Report this comment

    Daisy Roots

    Wednesday, September 5, 2012

  • ....Ofsted data shows that 99.7 per cent of schools have pupil behaviour which is described by inspectors as at least satisfactory......I would guess 'satisfactory' means they haven't burned the school down, lynched a teacher or set up a cannabis factory within the school. We can assume the remaining 0.3% managed at least one of these. distinctions.

    Report this comment


    Wednesday, September 5, 2012

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site


Most Read

Most Commented

Latest from the EDP



max temp: 6°C

min temp: 6°C

Listen to the latest weather forecast

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the EDP
digital edition


Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter