Search

Free with the EDP and Evening News on Friday - 56-page Wembley Souvenir Picture Special Pink Un

Review: Salmon Fishing In the Yemen

16:21 20 April 2012

Salmon Fishing In The Yemen

Salmon Fishing In The Yemen

Archant

This has all the default elements of a Quality Brit Flick – an adaptation of a lauded and popular novel, an inspiring against-the-odds tale, the put-upon little guy who finds himself, a bit of Ealing-style whimsy, a script by Simon Beaufort (Full Monty, Slumdog) with a rogue element of current affairs and defanged political satire.

shares

It all then flows down to its inevitable destination – a romantic comedy in which an uncertain and awkward leading man wins over the ravishing leading lady.

Fred (Ewan McGregor) is a meagre man from the Fishing Ministries, who finds himself sucked up into an absurd PR ruse by government spin doctor Maxwell (Kristen Scott Thomas) to help a Yemeni sheik (Amr Waked) realise his dream of doing a spot of fishing in his arid homeland.

Emily Blunt is the banker entrusted with organising the project but who is concerned about the fate of her new soldier boyfriend (Tom Mison) who has just been sent to Afghanistan.

At one point, Blunt describes Fred as having Asperger’s and, in many ways, the film has a lot in common with Extremely Loud and Extremely Close, a cringing awkwardness born of trying to fit a novel into movie form.

It’s bold, yet timid. You can see the ideas and scope and ambition of the project but it is buried under a simpering layer of twee.

The sex of the Maxwell character has been changed to avoid direct comparisons with Malcolm Tucker but the political satire here is sub-Yes Minister.

Only fishing really stirs the film’s juices and the salmon are lovingly photographed in the kind of slow-motion, moving-through-cascading-water shots that Michael Bay usually lavishes on the leading lady in a Transformers film.

Like Extremely Loud, it has an unappealing main character. Fred is an uptight dullard and it takes all McGregor’s skill to make his emergence into a full human being credible.

Salmon Fishing should be a horrible thing, a whimpering cowardly bungling atrocity yet somehow McGregor and Blunt have the skill and charisma to make it bearable; perhaps even a hit.

SALMON FISHING IN THE YEMEN (12A)

Director: Lasse Hallström

Starring: Ewan McGregor, Emily Blunt, Kristen Scott Thomas, Amr Waked and Tom Mison

Length: 107 mins

**

shares

0 comments

Most Read

Campaigns

Most Commented

Partly Cloudy

Partly Cloudy

max temp: 16°C

min temp: 10°C

Listen to the latest weather forecast

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the EDP
digital edition

Subscribe

Broads Outdoor Festival

cover

Enjoy the Broads
Outdoor Festival
digital edition

Read

Eating Out in the Broads

cover

Enjoy the Eating Out
in the Broads
digital edition

Read

Great Days Out

cover

Enjoy the Great Days
Out digital edition

Read