Norwich City given demonstration of how NOT to referee at the highest level

PUBLISHED: 12:00 13 August 2015 | UPDATED: 13:55 13 August 2015

Cameron Jerome puts the ball in the net but the goal is disallowed for a high foot by referee Simon Hooper. Picture by Paul Chesterton/Focus Images Ltd

Cameron Jerome puts the ball in the net but the goal is disallowed for a high foot by referee Simon Hooper. Picture by Paul Chesterton/Focus Images Ltd

©Focus Images Limited +447814 482222

I am tempted to start this column in hushed tones...

Fab Four

1: Scot is growing influence for City - There were plenty of positives from Saturday’s game. Graham Dorrans’ influence continues to grow, fitness being the issue he faced upon arrival, Wes Hoolahan was the metronome once again and I was more impressed by Robbie Brady’s left-back debut than others seem to be. On Saturday I’d like to see Nathan Redmond in for Alex Tettey, Cameron Jerome for Lewis Grabban and Hoolahan to keep his place for a game Norwich already need to win or draw.

2: I’ve missed having vocal away fans - One of the things I miss most when Norwich drop down the leagues is proper noise and atmosphere from away fans. That may sound perverse, but it makes such a difference to the overall atmosphere inside Carrow Road to have a few thousand away fans, rather than a few hundred. Credit to Palace fans for Saturday’s performance, impressive in both numbers and noise.

3: Rudy could have done a job for us - Whether Norwich City were in for him we’ll never know, but I had to grimace on Saturday when I saw not only the Aston Villa result, but the scorer. Former Blackburn striker Rudy Gestede is exactly the player I hoped we’d see in yellow and green this season – and exactly the type of striker that City need.

4: Work to do for some outcasts - With most of the squad used during pre-season friendlies, the first game of the season always offer a good early indication of who the manager really rates. It already looks like it could be a long season for Tony Andreu, Vadis Odjidja-Ofoe, Ricky van Wolfswinkel, Kyle Lafferty, Elliott Bennett and Michael Turner.

My own football past includes a refereeing qualification at the age of 14, followed by a decade in which my preferred form of weekend entertainment was to don the all black kit, slip a pencil down the side of my string-tightened socks and officiate at football games.

There, I’ve said it, and the saying is right, it does feel better to get it out in the open.

And that experience, which ended upon deciding to instead concentrate on a ‘career’ as an enthusiastic but technically ungifted Sunday league centre back, has always contributed towards a desire not to use these column inches to berate referees.

It’s a hard enough job at the bottom rungs of the football ladder, let alone when the game is much faster and there are thousands in the crowd baying for your blood.

Over the years following Norwich City, I’ve tried to temper any ill-feeling towards poorly performing officials by reminding myself that even the best players in the world make spur of the moment mistakes.

It seems unfair to expect those in charge not to show the same human frailties. But, even several days on from City’s opening day defeat to Crystal Palace, the performance of referee Simon Hooper continues to grate to such an extent the rule book has been thrown out for the next few hundred words.

It wasn’t just the errors themselves that got under my skin on Saturday – but the failure to achieve even the most basic of refereeing standards.

At the very early stages of training, there are a number of golden rules officials-to-be are given about being a referee.

They’re basically the equivalent of a striker being told to score goals and a defender to stop them.

I’m sorry to say that Hooper broke several of these and while his performance wasn’t directly responsible for defeat – it certainly didn’t help matters.

The first focuses on how to act in the opening minutes of a game if the tackles are flying in. Dish out a yellow too soon and you’ve potentially set the game up to include too many needless bookings, act too late and it could potentially stop an official from getting proper control of the match.

Hooper acted too late and missed an opportunity to stamp his authority on the game when Glenn Murray should have been booked for a nasty foul on Graham Dorrans.

In the 90 minutes Palace committed 20 fouls without a booking. They knew the referee wasn’t going to clampdown on their foul play and used it to their advantage.

The best referees, or so they are told, should go relatively unnoticed, appreciating the fact their main aim is to help facilitate an entertaining game of football. Nothing rankles with players, managers and fans more than needless fussing.

Hooper, and his officials, did just that, repeatedly slowing up play by insisting free-kicks were taken again or the ball moved back a yard or two when it didn’t really need to be. It was a fantastically entertaining game in spite of their actions.

I’m sure he even made up his own rule at one point, when Wes Hoolahan went to take a quick free kick, a Palace player stuck his leg out and stopped it from two yards away.

The referee insisted it was the Irishman’s fault for taking it too quickly. Granted Hoolahan has a frustrating habit of wasting free-kicks by hurrying them, but I’m not aware that anywhere does it state a quickly taken one means the 10-yard rule no longer applies.

There’s one other golden rule Hooper spectacularly failed to adhere to; do not go chasing decisions, causing a controversy when there just doesn’t need to be one.

But that’s exactly what Hooper did in the ludicrous decision to disallow Cameron Jerome’s, inset, wonderful goal. Not even Alan Pardew, with all his touchline emotion, was disputing it in the aftermath.

But still Hooper insisted action should be taken. I’ve also been wondering if his failure to award City a penalty was borne out by the fact he didn’t want to be seen to be redressing the balance for his earlier error.

If so, Saturday would have been a good time to remind Mr Hooper of that old saying two wrongs don’t make a right.


  • He just looks a twerp.

    Report this comment

    harry mcardle

    Thursday, August 13, 2015

  • I am amazed that a sport with so much money virtually ignores modern technology. Both rugby codes, cricket, tennis and hockey, to name a few, all use replays and extra officials to god effect. It is no good saying that it will slow the game down, hockey is a much faster game and it works well. Why is there an offside rule? Cut out offside as hockey did years ago and make the game better. Too much money is wasted in this game which is no longer "the beautiful one" it once was.

    Report this comment


    Thursday, August 13, 2015

  • Well written article. The man should take stock of it. Focus on Saturday now. Need a win there.

    Report this comment

    Bill Punton's bald patch

    Thursday, August 13, 2015

  • It was a disgusting display that ruined the game for Norwich and impartial fans. It would have been a great spectacle of finale, and it's an entertainment sport. This ref, like so many others, sees it as their duty to ruin the game and take centre stage. The FA hopefully get numerous phonecalls from a double dose of McNasty based on that disgraceful experiment.

    Report this comment


    Thursday, August 13, 2015

  • that man should not be allowed to referee under 10s or sunday pub leagues.appalling performance,certainly cost city at least a point possibly 3,can we send him the bill for lost revenue if the unthinkable happens at the end of the season.its refs like this that can cost you the whole season,something has to be done,perhaps a 4th official to review disputed decisions,instant replay for officials as the nfl does.i dont mean review every throw in or free kick but certainly for reviewing CJ,s goal and the penalty shout, in fact any game changing occurrence.,even the most impatient fan would welcome the odd stoppage if it prevented a travesty like we had on saturday. what ever happens its obvious that "sooper hooper"should not be allowed to officiate at the highest level again.

    Report this comment

    Trevor Frammingham

    Thursday, August 13, 2015

  • I can just imagine David Powles grinding his teeth as he wrote the article. Why is it that city always seem to host a new referee? It appears the power's that be seem to think that little old Norwich won't mind the man in black learning his trade at our expense. Very poor performance ref

    Report this comment


    Thursday, August 13, 2015

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Most Read

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most Commented

Latest from the EDP



max temp: 7°C

min temp: 7°C

Listen to the latest weather forecast

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the EDP
digital edition