Booing was unhelpful ahead of inevitable tough top-flight spell for Norwich City

06:30 31 October 2015

From the archive: Damien Francis, pictured challenging Manchester City's Nicolas Anelka, was on target for Norwich City in a 1-1 draw at the City of Manchester Stadium during the 2004/05 season. Picture: Martin Rickett/PA

From the archive: Damien Francis, pictured challenging Manchester City's Nicolas Anelka, was on target for Norwich City in a 1-1 draw at the City of Manchester Stadium during the 2004/05 season. Picture: Martin Rickett/PA

I think we all realised that City would hit a bad patch at some point this season. The only real surprise has been how suddenly it has arrived and just how bad it appears to be.

Leaving Upton Park in late September after a near-perfect away performance against a very good side there was every reason to believe that, with nine points from seven games and two home matches interspersed with a trip to the Premier League’s bottom club to look forward to, City could reasonably expect to be in a comfortable position by Halloween.

Three defeats later the world looks a very different place and with three games in the next four against Manchester City, Chelsea and Arsenal, league points could be at a premium in the coming month.

I wrote last week that we could expect opposing sides to sit back and look to catch City on the break until such time as Alex Neil came up with an answer, and so it proved against West Brom, but what was really worrying about the performance was the fact that despite a noticeably more restrained approach to throwing players forward which limited the number of chances created, City still succumbed to a sucker punch.

The goal itself was horrible from a Canaries perspective as a quick break saw James McClean offered all the time in the world in the vacant right-back channel to pick out a cross of infinitely more quality than City’s much more numerous efforts that resulted in Salomón Rondón soaring above Sebastien Bassong to head home.

And once again it had been coming as City’s season-long struggle to defend effectively against balls into the box continued.

Just before half-time Craig Dawson had somehow managed to bounce a free header from four yards out over the City crossbar before Rondon had headed narrowly over as Bassong once again jumped like a man whose feet had been encased in concrete.

Defenders who are good on the ball are a great thing in principle, but unless they can do their fundamental job of keeping the ball out of the net it’s all just window dressing. Despite his limitations there were times on Saturday when I found myself yearning for Michael Turner, to whom a lost defensive header was a personal insult.

While City had swept forward regularly in the opening half-hour they created relatively few real problems for the typically obdurate defence that Tony Pulis had put his faith in, and it was only from wide positions that the home side were able to create opportunities, with any central passing becoming over-intricate and easily snuffed out by the massed ranks of striped shirts.

No one could argue that City are infinitely easier on the eye than Pulis’ team, but unless the Premier League start offering points for artistic merit this is starting to look like a long, hard season unless Neil can resolve his side’s defensive deficiencies.

My other big concern was the reaction to going behind. Rather than regroup and stick to the game plan the ball suddenly became a hot potato for too many City players, and the high pressing that characterised their early-season success was noticeable by its absence.

However, these are still the same players who started the season so well and while the last thing that City need today is a visit to the Etihad we must at all costs continue to back Neil, who is having to learn hard lessons but hasn’t become a bad manager overnight, despite the unnecessary booing at the end of the game.

At Wembley we all stood together. That’s easy in successful times, but the true measure of support is doing so when the chips are down.


  • And booing brings the whole edifice crashing down? I fully accept people have a right to boo, I'm questioning firstly whether it actually contributes to better performances and secondly whether last week was a shocking performance or a shocking result. I would suggest it was the latter and hence the booing becomes more counter productive. Just my view of course, which has no more merit than anyone else's.

    Report this comment

    Robin Sainty

    Sunday, November 1, 2015

  • OK Robin , please applaud quietly and respectfully as City slide back to the championship. Dont forget to tug your forelock to The clubs upper echelon when you see them. Dont upset them.

    Report this comment


    Saturday, October 31, 2015

  • I'm not a booer myself but how else do you get across to a very stubborn manager that you're not impressed? Unfounded Loyalty is costing us points every week. The fans will still be there long after the manager and players have departed and they care. The fans are not blind and when good players are sat on the bench without being given a chance whilst the same 11 are failing each week I cannot blame the natives from getting restless. Today's team will be very interesting but any changes of personnel much be given a run of games and not be judged purely on the next 4 games. OTBC

    Report this comment


    Saturday, October 31, 2015

  • Have played pretty much the bottom half of the division with one up front and shown a blinkered loyalty to a defence that is so obviously lacking in every position. No wonder the natives are getting restless now the big boys visits are on the horizon and so few points in the bag

    Report this comment

    justin opinion

    Saturday, October 31, 2015

  • Yer pays yer money yer boo's if yer like.

    Report this comment


    Saturday, October 31, 2015

  • The article is headed " booing was unhelpful...". The only mention of booing was at the end of the game.. Surely this is when fans have the best opportunity to voice their displeasure at the performance and the result. True NCFC fans will stay behind their team and support them vociferously during the match. Anyone who was there against WBA knows the performance was poor against a team most of us expected a decent result against. Letting the team know how they feel after the event is a paying supporters privilege whether good or bad.

    Report this comment


    Saturday, October 31, 2015

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

Most Read

Most Commented

Latest from the EDP



max temp: 9°C

min temp: 9°C

Listen to the latest weather forecast

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition


Enjoy the EDP
digital edition


Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter