Tories unveil energy price cap ‘to save families £100 a year’ - but industry sceptical
Theresa May has confirmed the Conservatives will cap “rip off” gas and electricity prices - saving families up to £100 a year - if they are returned to power in the general election on June 8.
The prime minister said 17 million households will benefit from the cap on poor value standard variable tariffs (SVTs) as part of her drive to stand up for ordinary working families.
The Tories were accused of stealing former Labour leader Ed Miliband’s plans for an energy price freeze when the plan was first trailed last month.
At the time, then prime minister David Cameron denounced the plan and accused Mr Miliband of wanting to live in a “Marxist universe”.
But in an article for The Sun, Mrs May said the energy market is not working and the government needs to intervene.
MORE: Energy cap could reduce competition, warn East Anglian experts
Mrs May wrote: “Like millions of working families, I am fed up with rip off energy prices.
“Too many people simply aren’t getting a fair deal. And it is the vulnerable, and those on low incomes, who are being hit hardest.
“So I am making this promise: if I am re-elected on June 8, I will take action to end this injustice by introducing a cap on unfair energy price rises.”
How would it work?
Under the Tory plan, the cap would be set by the independent regulator for the energy market, Ofgem.
Justifying the move, the Conservatives pointed to a report last year by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) which found 70% of domestic customers of the “Big Six” energy companies were on SVTs.
The CMA calculated that cost to consumers of “excessive prices” charged by the Big Six to be about £1.4bn a year.
Labour’s shadow business secretary Rebecca Long-Bailey said the Conservatives had still not provided any proper detail as to how the cap would work.
“When the Tories say they’ll ‘cap’ bills, the question they need to answer is whether they can guarantee bills won’t go up for people next year - that’s the real test,” she said.
“A cap suggests a maximum amount that can be charged, not a promise that bills won’t go up year on year.”
For the Liberal Democrats, former energy secretary Sir Ed Davey said: “It is never a good idea to copy the economic strategy of Ed Miliband.
“As the Conservatives pointed out at the time, this will damage investment in energy when it is needed more than ever.”
What does the industry think?
British Gas owner Centrica has hit out at the proposed cap, warning that it could lead to higher bills for consumers and reduce competition in the sector.
In a trading update, the group said it had put forward “alternative ways” to improve the market and address concerns as part of its regular dialogue with ministers.
“Centrica does not believe in any form of price regulation. Evidence from other countries would suggest this will lead to reduced competition and choice, and potentially higher average prices,” it said.
“We have had a regular and constructive dialogue with the Government and have proposed alternative ways to improve the market further and address their concerns, without resorting to price regulation.”